By now you’re all caught up on Danny Masterson’s 30 years in prison sentence for rape. You’ve heard about the character letters written in his favor by Ashton Kutcher and Mila Kunis. However, according to one of Masterson’s ex-girlfriends, and victims, that isn’t even half of the story surrounding these detestable Hollywood figures.


The letters created so much backlash that Kutcher and Kunis issued an apology over the weekend in which they were criticized for appearing “cold and unapologetic.” The immense backlash to their character letters came from not just those following the trial but someone a part of it.


Chrissie Carnell-Bixler, referred to as Jane Doe 3 in the case against Masterson, accused her ex-boyfriend of raping her in her sleep in 2001. While the verdicts between Jane Doe 1 and 2 were decided, the jury was deadlocked on Carnell-Bixler’s case.


After Kuther’s and Kunis’ letters were made public, Carnell-Bixler took to Instagram to remind Kutcher (and the world) that she knows a few of his own “secrets.”



“Dear Ashton, I know your secrets your “role model” keeps for you. Ones that would end you. Did you forget that I was there? You were on speaker phone the night you called Danny on February 21, 2001. I heard everything. I heard the plan. In my opinion you’re just as sick as your ‘mentor,’” she wrote on her story.


The night of February 21, 2001, Kutcher had a date with Ashley Ellerin, a young woman he briefly dated, and who was murdered by Michael Gargiulo, aka, the ‘Holywood Ripper.’


In 2019, Kutcher testified in Gargiulo’s trial, saying he knocked on Ellerin’s door multiple times that night and was left with no option but to leave after he was given no response. Kutcher has stated that as soon as he learned that Ellerin had been killed he immediately called the police as “his fingerprints were all over her doorknob.”


Carnell-Bixler’s cryptic Instagram posts have many people wondering: What is she insinuating?



Carnell-Bixler also encouraged people to look up old interviews of Kunis and Kutcher, specifically from the early days of their That ‘70s Show tenure when Kunis was still underage.


“I also know what happened in Toronto and after. Question, if that’s what you view as a normal relationship with a “big brother figure” then I feel very sad for you. And I hope you consider getting into therapy,” she addresses to Kunis.



Though the speculation behind Carnell-Bixler’s cryptic story remains unanswered, what we do know is if you’re going to release an apology video, you have to try and appear sad. Come on, you’re actors!